Cash value and agreed value
Most car insurance pays actual cash value after a total loss: what the car was worth just before the crash, worked out afterward from its age, mileage, condition, and sales of similar cars. For a five-year-old sedan, that works. There are thousands of them for sale, and the price is easy to find.
For some cars, it doesn't. A restored roadster, a low-mileage coupe someone kept for twenty years, or a modified car with receipts for every part can be worth far more than a pricing guide says. The guide goes by the year and the model and can't see the work.
Agreed value fixes the number in advance. We set it together when the car goes on the policy, and it is written on your declarations page. If the car is totaled, we pay the agreed value or the actual cash value, whichever is higher, with no deductible. Varies by state
Agreed value comes with the Collector level, and you can use it on any car on the policy.
Which cars need it
A car is a good fit for agreed value when its real worth would be hard to prove after it is gone. That usually means one or more of these:
- It has been restored, or has had major work you have receipts for.
- It is old enough, or rare enough, that few similar cars sell near you.
- It is worth more today than when you bought it.
- It is a weekend car you have kept in better shape than the average one of its kind.
A newer daily car with plenty of similar cars for sale rarely needs it. Its cash value is easy to check, and the higher-of rule already protects you if prices rise.
How a value is agreed
You propose a number and show us why. Depending on the car, we ask for some or all of these:
- An appraisal. A recent written appraisal from an appraiser who knows the make and era.
- Photos. All four sides, the interior, the engine bay, the odometer, and any damage or wear.
- Records. Restoration and parts receipts, service history, and sale prices of comparable cars.
We read what you send. If the number fits the evidence, we accept it. If we think it is high or low, we tell you why and suggest a different one, and you can send more. Nothing goes on the policy until we both agree.
A higher agreed value can raise the premium for that car, because there is more to pay out if it is lost.
Example, not a quote or a claim decision
A restored 1991 roadster, totaled in a parking lot
On Household, with no agreed value. The cash value is worked out after the crash from ordinary sales of the same model.
- Restoration receipts on file
- $21,000
- Actual cash value after the crash
- $19,500
- Deductible on a total loss
- $0
- We pay
- $19,500
On Collector. The owner sent an appraisal, photos, and the restoration receipts when the car went on the policy.
- Agreed value on the declarations page
- $34,000
- Actual cash value after the crash
- $19,500
- Deductible on a total loss
- $0
- We pay the higher number
- $34,000
Before renewal, the owner sends a new appraisal after similar roadsters sold for more.
- Agreed value last term
- $34,000
- New appraisal, with fresh photos
- $38,000
- Agreed value from renewal
- $38,000
The premium for that car goes up a little with the higher value.
Made-up numbers to show how the rule works. Real values depend on the car and the evidence.
Reviewing it at renewal
Values move. A model can come into fashion, or fall out of it. You might rebuild the engine, or the paint might age. An agreed value set three years ago can be too high or too low today.
Before each renewal, look at the number on your declarations page and ask whether you could replace the car for it. If you couldn't, send us a new appraisal or the receipts for the work. You can ask to lower it too. If you finish major work in the middle of a term, you don't need to wait for renewal; send the records when the work is done.
What agreed value does not change
Agreed value only sets what we pay when the car is a total loss. Flip the tag for what it leaves out.
Agreed value
A total-loss payment of the agreed number or the cash value, whichever is higher, with no deductible.
Varies by state
Agreed value
Doesn't cover: Partial damage, which is paid as a repair; mechanical breakdown, wear, or rust; and work added after the value was set, until you send the records.
Repairs on a Collector car can go to a specialist shop you choose, so a smaller accident is handled by someone who knows the car.
Policy documents govern. This guide is a plain summary; your policy's own wording decides what is covered.


