04 Guides

What happens if your car is totaled and you still owe on it

We pay the higher of the agreed value or the actual cash value, with no deductible. If that is less than the loan, gap payoff covers most of what is left.

A low gray sedan parked alone at the curb of a quiet street of modern homes, long shadow on the asphalt
A quiet street, late afternoon

When a car is a total loss

A car is totaled when fixing it would cost more than it is worth, or close to it. Each state sets its own threshold. Some use a percentage of the car's value, others a formula that adds the repair cost to what the wreck would sell for. Varies by state

The adjuster makes the call after inspecting the car, and tells you how the number was reached. You don't have to accept a total-loss decision you think is wrong. Say so, and send what you have.

What we pay

Two numbers decide a total-loss payment.

  • Actual cash value. What the car was worth the moment before the crash, based on its age, mileage, condition, options, and recent sales of similar cars near you.
  • Agreed value. A number we set with you when the car goes on the policy, written on your declarations page. It comes with Collector, for any car on the policy.

We pay whichever is higher. If a car has no agreed value, we pay its actual cash value.

There is no deductible on a total loss. If your collision deductible is $1,000, that $1,000 is not taken out of the payment. Varies by state

If the cash value looks low, tell the adjuster why. Service records, receipts for new tires or recent work, and listings of similar cars all count. We look at the number again with what you send.

If you owe more than the car is worth

A car can lose value faster than a loan is paid down, more so with a small down payment, a long loan term, or a lease. When that car is totaled, the cash value goes to the lender, and the rest of the balance is still yours to pay on a car you no longer have.

Gap payoff, part of Household and Collector, pays that difference. It covers the loan or lease balance left after the total-loss payment, and it is paid to the lender.

What gap payoff leaves out

Some amounts in a loan balance are not the car's value, and gap payoff does not pay them. Flip the tag to see the list.

Gap payoff

The loan or lease balance left after the total-loss payment, paid to your lender.

Varies by state

Gap payoff

Doesn't cover: Overdue payments, lease mileage penalties, unrefunded deposits, add-on warranties, and rolled-over balances.

  • Overdue payments. Missed payments and their late fees stay with you.
  • Lease mileage penalties. Charges for miles over the lease allowance.
  • Unrefunded deposits. A security deposit the leasing company keeps.
  • Add-on warranties. Extended warranties, service contracts, and similar extras financed into the loan. Many can be canceled for a partial refund; ask whoever sold them.
  • Rolled-over balances. Money still owed on an earlier car that was folded into this loan.

Example, not a quote or a claim decision

Three total losses, three payments

A weekend coupe on Collector, agreed value written on the policy.

Agreed value
$42,000
Actual cash value after the crash
$37,500
Deductible on a total loss
$0
We pay the higher number
$42,000

The same coupe a year later, after prices for that model went up.

Agreed value
$42,000
Actual cash value after the crash
$45,500
Deductible on a total loss
$0
We pay the higher number
$45,500

A financed daily sedan on Household, no agreed value.

Loan balance on the day of the crash
$31,400
Actual cash value, paid to the lender
-$26,000
Left on the loan
$5,400
Not paid: add-on warranty in the loan
-$1,200
Not paid: one overdue payment
-$520
Gap payoff to the lender
$3,680

The owner pays the $1,720 left, and can ask the warranty seller about a partial refund.

Made-up numbers to show the order of the math. Real values come from the adjuster's review.

How the payment goes

Once the adjuster has a number, you get the valuation in writing with the sales it was based on. When you accept it, you sign the title over to us and we pay in this order:

  • The lender or leasing company first, up to the payoff amount.
  • Gap payoff next, if the car is on Household or Collector and a balance is left.
  • You, if the payment is more than the loan.

Have the lender's name and your account number ready, plus the title if you hold it. If you'd rather hold on to the car, ask the adjuster; in many states you can, and the payment is reduced by what the wreck would sell for. Varies by state

Policy documents govern. This guide is a plain summary; your policy's own wording decides what is covered.

See what each level pays after a total loss.

Set the drivers and each car's use in the builder for an example monthly total, or start a quote: three steps, and nothing is sent.